[compiler] Add ImmutableCapture effect, CreateFrom no longer needs Capture #33367
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
…pture ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
This was referenced May 27, 2025
This was referenced May 27, 2025
josephsavona
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
May 28, 2025
…pture ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. ghstack-source-id: fef144d Pull Request resolved: #33367
github-actions
bot
added
the
React Core Team
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
This was referenced May 30, 2025
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
This was referenced Jun 4, 2025
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
…er needs Capture" ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the `from` value is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add a `Copy` effect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet. Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives. A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated. [ghstack-poisoned]
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Stack from ghstack (oldest at bottom):
ImmutableCapture allows us to record information flow for escape analysis purposes, without impacting mutable range analysis. All of Alias, Capture, and CreateFrom now downgrade to ImmutableCapture if the
fromvalue is frozen. Globals and primitives are conceptually copy types and don't record any information flow at all. I guess we could add aCopyeffect if we wanted but i haven't seen a need for it yet.Related, previously CreateFrom was always paired with Capture when constructing effects. But I had also coded up the inference to sort of treat them the same. So this diff makes that official, and means CreateFrom is a valid third way to represent data flow and not just creation. When applied, CreateFrom will turn into: ImmutableCapture for frozen values, Capture for mutable values, and disappear for globals/primitives.
A final tweak is to change range inference to ensure that range.start is non-zero if the value is mutated.