Skip to content

Conversation

meetrpatels30
Copy link

No description provided.

@super30admin
Copy link
Owner

The student's solutions demonstrate a good understanding of fundamental algorithms and data structures. Here's a detailed evaluation for each exercise:

  1. Exercise_1.js (Binary Search):
  • Correctness: The implementation correctly follows the binary search algorithm.
  • Time Complexity: Correctly identified as O(log n).
  • Space Complexity: Correctly identified as O(1).
  • Code Quality: Well-structured with clear comments. The edge case for empty array is handled.
  • Improvement: The base case (left === right) is unnecessary since the while loop handles it.
  1. Exercise_2.js (QuickSort):
  • Correctness: Proper implementation of QuickSort with correct partitioning.
  • Time Complexity: Correctly identified as O(n log n) average and O(n²) worst case.
  • Space Complexity: Correctly identified as O(log n) due to recursion stack.
  • Code Quality: Good structure with helper methods. The swap method could be made static since it doesn't use instance properties.
  • Improvement: Could add check for already sorted array to optimize.
  1. Exercise_3.js (Linked List Middle Element):
  • Correctness: Correct implementation using fast and slow pointers.
  • Time Complexity: Correctly identified as O(n).
  • Space Complexity: Correctly identified as O(1).
  • Code Quality: Well-structured with proper class usage. The printMiddle method could return the value instead of just printing.
  • Improvement: The printList call inside the loop is inefficient for demonstration.
  1. Exercise_4.js (MergeSort):
  • Correctness: Proper implementation of MergeSort with correct merging.
  • Time Complexity: Correctly identified as O(n log n).
  • Space Complexity: Correctly identified as O(n).
  • Code Quality: Well-structured with clear separation of concerns. Good use of helper methods.
  • Improvement: Could optimize by checking if subarrays are already sorted before merging.

General Strengths:

  • Consistent coding style
  • Proper comments and documentation
  • Correct time/space complexity analysis
  • Good handling of edge cases

General Areas for Improvement:

  • Some redundant checks could be removed
  • Methods that don't use instance properties could be made static
  • Some demonstration code could be more efficient
  • Could add more test cases for edge scenarios

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants