docs: add TakeProfit Lotus chart and quote-status judgment

[safal207]

Summary

Adds a bounded TakeProfit external-QA Lotus judgment on top of the Tradernet case in PR #235 and refines it with the latest LiminalQA chart, outage, application-order, and paired quote-block evidence.

Judgment

Verdict: ESCALATE

Two bounded P2 findings are confirmed for human reporting:

1. ChartStore initialization regression — the public BTC/USDT indicator chart starts with missing required ChartStore fields and repeats the validation failure after reload. The historical family remains STILL_PRESENT_IN_CHANGED_FORM.
2. Icon-only quote-connectivity state — when current ListQuotes requests are unavailable, the public chart remains fully visible and plausible while the only visible connection-state change is disappearance of a small green icon next to BYBIT. No textual offline, stale, delayed, disconnected, reconnecting, snapshot, or last-updated state appears.

The second finding is CONFIRMED_ICON_ONLY_STATE_LOSS.

Exact paired evidence

LiminalQA run 29666238811 on exact head:

18d703929c31d53789814890a3565550283d5120

• three fresh baseline/treatment pairs;
• baseline received 2 / 1 / 1 quote responses;
• treatment blocked 1 / 2 / 2 naturally initiated quote requests;
• chart remained visible in 3/3 treatments;
• page body text remained identical in 3/3 pairs;
• the same bounded pixel region changed in all pairs: x=148..193, y=8..27;
• the green signal icon disappeared and the 1h control shifted left;
• candles, indicator lines, axes, price labels, and body text remained unchanged.

Artifact digest:

sha256:6900d32df4805706dc1ec8cc9d19f409e079c9ebbde6b907fce20d0534328838

Raw result SHA-256:

cd57984cc134fd4ea99861e0640388fc712795eac4f86e637dd766fdbead0838

Causal corrections

• steady-state polling was serialized while the second non-empty response remained pending in three 90-second rounds;
• the earlier older-after-newer transport delivery is scoped to first-load overlap, not steady-state polling;
• visible rollback is not confirmed;
• the public chart is not proven to consume current quote payloads;
• the broad unused-polling hypothesis is rejected because the small status icon visibly depends on quote transport;
• 61516.2 is not classified as a stale current BTC price.

Lotus reading

Pythia

• ALLOW: the bounded icon-only state-visibility finding;
• BLOCK: numerical stale-price and visible-rollback claims;
• ESCALATE: whether the public chart is live, delayed, or an intentionally fixed published snapshot.

CML

Startup overlap, steady-state serialized polling, outage recovery, and icon-state dependency remain separately scoped memories. No shared root cause with ChartStore is claimed.

LS

A credible-looking financial chart remains visible while quote-connectivity loss has no visible textual equivalent, freshness timestamp, or accessible last-known-data state. This reduces informed user control.

Recommended product contract

Live · updated 2s ago
Delayed · last update 14:32:05
Offline · showing snapshot from 14:31:00

Deliverables

• examples/lotus-cases/takeprofit-public-chart-quote-judgment-v1.json
• docs/lotus-cases/TAKEPROFIT_PUBLIC_CHART_QUOTE_JUDGMENT.md
• test/lotus_external_qa_cases_contract_test.exs

Exact-head validation

Validated on 543bfdbf9ba7d1173565dfa51519cf741d2f34c9:

• CI run 29666593351 — success through compile, formatter, all Elixir tests, demos, benchmark, Rust worker build/tests, and port demo;
• Security run 29666593352 — Gitleaks success;
• temporary formatting workflow removed before final validation;
• packet SHA-256: 7443ffd0ad618a59656a4257d978af8e5a947532e3056e724e0ff0d86591b7a5.

Authority boundary

ESCALATE means present the two bounded findings to an authorized human owner. It grants no ownership, approval, execution, delivery, external-submission, or merge authority.

Stack

This draft is based on agent/tradernet-lotus-judgment-v0-1 / PR #235 so both external financial-platform judgments use the same schema and authority boundary.

[coderabbitai]

Important

Review skipped

Draft detected.

Please check the settings in the CodeRabbit UI or the .coderabbit.yaml file in this repository. To trigger a single review, invoke the @coderabbitai review command.

⚙️ Run configuration

Configuration used: defaults

Review profile: CHILL

Plan: Pro Plus

Run ID: d94f996d-3a46-4669-bc24-8718ad5368e5

You can disable this status message by setting the reviews.review_status to false in the CodeRabbit configuration file.

Use the checkbox below for a quick retry:

• 🔍 Trigger review

✨ Finishing Touches

🧪 Generate unit tests (beta)

• Create PR with unit tests
• Commit unit tests in branch agent/takeprofit-lotus-judgment-v0-1

---

Thanks for using CodeRabbit! It's free for OSS, and your support helps us grow. If you like it, consider giving us a shout-out.

❤️ Share

• X
• Mastodon
• Reddit
• LinkedIn

_{Comment @coderabbitai help to get the list of available commands.}

[safal207]

Exact-head Lotus validation

Validated on exact PR head:

53538c8798dcdf9019341784a8e0ed5e3178e970

GitHub Actions:

• CI run 29664508631 — success;
• Security run 29664508633 — success.

The exact-head CI completed:

• dependency resolution and compilation;
• mix format --check-formatted;
• all Elixir tests, including Pythia.LotusExternalQACasesContractTest;
• demos and benchmark;
• Rust worker build and tests;
• port demo.

The contract preserves:

• exactly one confirmed TakeProfit finding: the P2 ChartStore required-field regression in changed form;
• stale-price harm as NEEDS_LONGER_OUTAGE_EVIDENCE, not a confirmed defect;
• authenticated workspace and trading-decision impact as explicit unknowns;
• audit_only authority with ownership, approval, execution, delivery, external submission, and merge grants all false.

Packet SHA-256: 1de70835dcc22aec035beeca0c090447bbf7c6e3cda4f131f1bf029e33cf2f10

The temporary formatting workflow used to obtain exact mix format output was removed before this validation. All evidence from earlier PR heads is stale for merge disposition.

[safal207]

Exact-head Lotus validation

Validated on exact head:

8f0979e6acad6c28f9dcb1a0af082f5dc1901f2b

GitHub Actions completed successfully:

• CI run 29665684757 — success;
• Security run 29665684781 — success.

CI passed:

• dependency resolution and compilation;
• Elixir formatting;
• the full Elixir test suite, including the updated external-QA Lotus contract;
• demos and benchmark;
• Rust port-worker build and tests;
• port demo.

Security passed Gitleaks secret scanning.

Confirmed bounded TakeProfit findings

1. P2 — ChartStore required-field regression remains STILL_PRESENT_IN_CHANGED_FORM.
2. P2 — public BTC/USDT chart lacks an explicit freshness/connection boundary during three independent 90–120 second browser-level network outages, with zero quote responses during each outage and successful quote recovery after every restore.

Freshness evidence source:

• LiminalQA PR fix(site): quickstart step cards — wrap long commands #63;
• run 29665413400;
• exact evidence head fe17c3ddad4e4540d91cb30ba40456f2114dc997;
• artifact digest sha256:2064e033deae3895e647ec11ba0541aecd2947d614ab03a07bf19089a132dafd;
• runner evidence SHA-256 0625dcd4f97a161bc0610ff31735fb8c399082a718f6678fd8bb9c921af9c73f.

Lotus packet SHA-256:

a5d09cb2e29330be742fab3ee447a559f748239983b7080803613bbe2cce13cc

The packet remains audit_only. Ownership, approval, execution, delivery, external-submission, and merge grants are false. Numerical price inaccuracy, authenticated workspace behavior, visible rollback, and trading-decision impact remain explicit unknowns.

Older-head validation evidence is stale.

[safal207]

Final exact-head Lotus evidence

Validated on exact PR head:

543bfdbf9ba7d1173565dfa51519cf741d2f34c9

• CI run 29666593351: success through compile, mix format --check-formatted, all Elixir tests including the updated TakeProfit external-QA contract, demos, benchmark, Rust worker build/tests, and port demo.
• Security run 29666593352: Gitleaks success.
• Temporary formatter workflow was removed before final validation.
• Machine packet SHA-256: 7443ffd0ad618a59656a4257d978af8e5a947532e3056e724e0ff0d86591b7a5.

Final bounded decision:

• P2 ChartStore initialization regression — confirmed;
• P2 icon-only quote-connectivity state — confirmed;
• numerical stale-price, visible rollback, authenticated-workspace behavior, and live/delayed/snapshot product intent remain blocked or escalated rather than overclaimed;
• authority remains audit_only, with all consequential grants false.