Skip to content

Conversation

@Merango
Copy link

@Merango Merango commented May 6, 2025

Implement Robust Error Handling for Duplicate Evidence Submissions

Original Task

Develop Error Handling and Logging for Duplicate Evidence

Summary of Changes

This pull request adds comprehensive error handling and logging mechanisms for duplicate evidence submissions to improve system reliability and user experience.

Acceptance Criteria

Create a custom DuplicateEvidenceError class
Log duplicate submission attempts with source IP, timestamp, and evidence details
Provide clear, actionable error messages to API consumers
Implement rate limiting for repeated duplicate submissions
90% test coverage for error handling and logging components

Tests

  • Test custom DuplicateEvidenceError class creation
  • Verify logging of duplicate submission details
  • Check rate limiting functionality
  • Validate error message clarity and informativeness
  • Ensure comprehensive test coverage for error handling components

@SatoshiShibanuma
Copy link

PR Review: Complex Multi-Project Repository Structure Review

Recommendation: REJECT

Justification

  • Repository structure does not match specified requirements
  • Multiple projects with complex directory structures
  • No single implementation or test file

Summary of Changes

The repository contains multiple microservices and tasks across different directories including agent-framework, feature-builder, middle-server, side-project, summarizer, and test-framework.

Requirements Review

✅ Met Requirements

All requirements need work

❌ Unmet Requirements

  • Implementation is in a single file in the /src directory
  • Tests are in a single file in the /tests directory
  • No other files are modified

Test Evaluation

Coverage

No adequate test coverage found

Issues in Existing Tests

  • Multiple test directories across different projects
  • No single unified test structure

Missing Test Cases

  • Unified test framework
  • Consistent test location
  • Single implementation file

Action Items

  • Restructure repository to have a single implementation in /src
  • Consolidate tests in /tests directory
  • Ensure no extraneous file modifications
  • Clarify the specific implementation and test requirements

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants