Skip to content

Conversation

@mexemexe
Copy link

@mexemexe mexemexe commented May 6, 2025

Implement Server-Side Evidence Uniqueness Validation

Original Task

Implement Server-Side Evidence Uniqueness Validation

Summary of Changes

This pull request adds comprehensive server-side validation to ensure evidence uniqueness, preventing duplicate submissions and improving system integrity.

Acceptance Criteria

Create a uniqueness validation method that checks against existing evidence records
Implement a caching layer to quickly reject duplicate submissions
Log all duplicate submission attempts with detailed error information
Return a 409 Conflict HTTP status for duplicate submissions
100% unit test coverage for uniqueness validation logic
Uniqueness check completes in less than 50ms

Tests

  • Verify uniqueness validation method against existing records
  • Test caching layer performance for duplicate rejection
  • Validate logging of duplicate submission attempts
  • Confirm 409 Conflict status for duplicate submissions
  • Ensure unit test coverage for uniqueness validation
  • Measure uniqueness check performance

@sbsmith09
Copy link

PR Review: Complex Multi-Project Repository Update

Recommendation: REVISE

Justification

  • Repository structure does not match specified requirements
  • Multiple src and tests directories across different projects
  • Unclear which specific implementation is being modified

Summary of Changes

Pull request contains updates across multiple projects and microservices within the Koii Network builder repository.

Requirements Review

✅ Met Requirements

All requirements need work

❌ Unmet Requirements

  • Single implementation file in /src
  • Single test file in /tests
  • No modifications to other files

Test Evaluation

Coverage

No adequate test coverage found

Issues in Existing Tests

  • Multiple test directories across different projects
  • No clear single test suite

Missing Test Cases

  • Unified test strategy
  • Centralized test configuration

Action Items

  • Clarify which specific task/project is being updated
  • Consolidate implementation to a single file in /src
  • Consolidate tests to a single file in /tests
  • Provide detailed problem description
  • Ensure no unintended file modifications

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants