aimasteracc · aimasteracc · Jun 4, 2026 · Jun 4, 2026
@@ -47,3 +47,4 @@ DECISIONS_CONTENT_PLACEHOLDER
 {"ts":"2026-06-04T04:10:00Z","agent":"orchestrator","action":"pm-dispatch","decision":"PM dispatch v33 (2026-06-04): (1) Pre-flight: CHARTER §2/§5.1/§5.10/§5.12/§5.13, _orchestrator.md, anti-patterns (hits: release-governance squash-merge DCO strip + repair-depth wrong), decisions tail (latest: v32 entry above), PM state (v32 on PR #521 open; v28 on develop), v0.2 PRD. (2) Assessed 2 open PRs: #521 (PM v32 chore, 22/22 CI ✅ on original commit BUT 2 Codex P1 findings unresolved: wrong HEAD~2 rebase depth + dangerous main-push fallback), #515 (release/v0.1.20 → main, DCO FAILURE, Quality Gate red). 0 open P0/P1 issues. (3) Root cause analysis: (a) PR #515 DCO: commits `9b51c35` + `39808637` are squash-merged with only Codex rejection text in body — no valid `Signed-off-by: Name <email>` trailer. (b) PR #521 Codex P1 #1: `HEAD~2` would replay only top-2 commits (release-bump + PM-dispatch), leaving unsigned commits at HEAD~3+HEAD~2 intact. Correct depth is HEAD~4. (c) PR #521 Codex P1 #2: ceremony-script fallback had `git push origin main` which pushes unsigned commits to main bypassing the red PR — exactly the bypass rejected from PR #518. (4) Actions: (a) `git rebase --signoff HEAD~4` on `release/v0.1.20` + `git push --force-with-lease` → PR #515 CI re-triggered. (b) Pushed fix commit `374bf8e` to `chore/pm-dispatch-2026-06-04-v32`: corrected HEAD~4 everywhere (5 locations) + removed dangerous fallback. (c) Replied to both Codex P1 findings with 'Fixed' justifications. (d) Updated PM state v33, appended this entry.","rationale":"Two distinct P0 actions were fully unblocked: (1) DCO repair on release/v0.1.20 — mechanical git rebase, no code risk, force-push to non-main/develop branch is standard practice. (2) Codex P1×2 on PR #521 — genuine documentation bugs (wrong count → under-repairs DCO; dangerous fallback → bypasses release gate). Both are required before PR #521 can merge per Charter Codex rule. Applying DCO fix autonomously rather than escalating to founder saves ceremony turnaround time; the rebase is idempotent and verifiable from the force-push log.","ref":"PR#521,PR#515,Charter§5.12,CLAUDE.md-Codex-rule","artifacts":{"dco_fix":"git rebase --signoff HEAD~4 on release/v0.1.20 (new HEAD 42137d3)","pr_521_fix_commit":"374bf8e (HEAD~4 + remove fallback)","codex_p1_both_fixed":true,"pm_state_updated":"v33","escalations":["founder: PR #515 CI re-running — merge when green + push tag v0.1.20 + GitHub Release","founder: add .github/dco.yml allowRemediationCommits:true"]}}
 {"ts":"2026-06-04T04:35:00Z","agent":"orchestrator","action":"pm-dispatch","decision":"PM dispatch v34 (2026-06-04): Deep DCO fix on release/v0.1.20 — HEAD~16 rebase covering all 16 non-merge commits. DCO check: SUCCESS on PR #515.","rationale":"v33's HEAD~4 rebase was insufficient: only the top-4 commits were replayed, but 2 older squash-merge commits (4bdc4de ADR-0010 at HEAD~7, bb685def get_callees at HEAD~10) also lacked Signed-off-by. Full audit: `git log --no-merges origin/main..HEAD` showed 16 non-merge commits above the safe base 8ffcad9 (Merge PR #494 v0.1.19→main). Ran `git rebase --signoff HEAD~16` on fix-dco-release-v0.1.20 branch — all 16 commits now carry Signed-off-by. Force-pushed to origin/release/v0.1.20. DCO check verified: conclusion=success on PR #515. Remaining CI (clippy/rustfmt/unit-tests/e2e) still in progress. Lesson: anti-pattern audit range must cover the FULL commit range origin/main..release-HEAD, not just the visibly-failing commits.","ref":"PR#515,Charter§5.12","artifacts":{"rebase_cmd":"git rebase --signoff HEAD~16 (HEAD~16=8ffcad9, 16 non-merge commits)","previously_unsigned":["4bdc4de→d0f6b74 (docs:ADR-0010)","bb685def→0bc266e (feat:get_callees)"],"dco_check":"conclusion=success (job 79448943661)","new_release_head":"07226070129415b0429c493beb39d24054c45432","escalations":["founder: PR #515 all CI completing — merge when green + push tag v0.1.20 + GitHub Release","founder: add .github/dco.yml allowRemediationCommits:true"]}}
 {"ts":"2026-06-04T05:10:00Z","agent":"orchestrator","action":"pm-dispatch","decision":"PM dispatch v35 (2026-06-04): Fixed Codex P1 on PR #522 — incorrect .github/dco.yml recommendation corrected in PM state v35; PR #515 confirmed 44/44 CI green; founder ceremony unblocked.","rationale":"Codex P1 on PR #522 line 190 was a genuine documentation bug: the recommendation to add '.github/dco.yml with allowRemediationCommits:true' would have zero effect because the CI gate is a custom shell script in ci.yml lines 205-229 (not the GitHub DCO App). The recommendation could have misdirected the founder into a false fix, allowing the systemic DCO problem to recur. The correct fix (update dco-check script to grep full message body, OR switch release.yml merge to direct git push) was substituted at all 3 affected locations. PR #515 was independently confirmed as 44/44 CI SUCCESS/SKIPPED with 0 Codex findings — the ceremony is fully unblocked pending founder merge.","ref":"PR#522,PR#515,Charter§5.12,CLAUDE.md-Codex-rule","artifacts":{"codex_p1_fixed":"PR #522 line 190, 209, 232 — .github/dco.yml recommendation corrected","pr_515_status":"44/44 CI SUCCESS/SKIPPED, 0 Codex findings, ready for founder ceremony","pm_state_updated":"v35","escalations":["founder: merge PR #515 + push tag v0.1.20 + GitHub Release","founder: systemic DCO fix (update ci.yml dco-check OR switch release.yml to git push)"]}}
+{"ts":"2026-06-04T05:40:00Z","agent":"orchestrator","action":"pm-dispatch","decision":"PM dispatch v36 (2026-06-04): Recognized founder's strategic v0.2.0 release cut (commit 1105cc6d, 05:26Z, bump 0.1.19→0.2.0, RFC-0109+RFC-0102+RFC-0110 npm/bun). Merged PR #522 (chore/pm-dispatch v33, 20/20 CI green, Codex P1 replied by founder). Closed PR #515 (v0.1.20 superseded by v0.2.0 — same pattern as v0.1.17→v0.1.18). Opened PR #523 (release/v0.2.0→main). PM state updated to v36 reflecting v0.2.0 ceremony in progress.","rationale":"Founder's direct commit to release/v0.2.0 (author: aisheng.yu, aimasteracc@gmail.com) is unambiguous BDFL authorization to cut v0.2.0 now. v0.1.20 crates were orphan-published (no git ceremony); same supersession strategy used for v0.1.17 and v0.1.15. v0.2.0 incorporates all v0.1.20 content plus RFC-0110 npm/bun which is the marquee 'Three-Surface Release' distribution feature. ETA accelerated from 2026-07-15 to 2026-06-04.","ref":"Charter§5.12,RFC-0109,RFC-0102,RFC-0110,PR#523,PR#522,PR#515","artifacts":{"merged_prs":["#522"],"closed_prs":["#515"],"opened_prs":["#523"],"pm_state":"v36","release_branch":"release/v0.2.0","release_workflow":"#26932722905 queued"}}