Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
{
"task": "build-docker-images-from-uv-lock",
"model": "us.anthropic.claude-opus-5-5",
"scores": {
"github_issue": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 20,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 87,
"notes": "The issue precisely identifies all nine tracked pyproject roots and the relevant Dockerfiles, matching the repository at tag 1.23.0. Its baseline claims are grounded: the Dockerfiles use `uv pip install`, four roots lack locks, and the root lock contains torch 2.9.1 plus CUDA and triton packages. The largest deficiency is that excluding the unpinned torch layers in the two full MCP images conflicts with the stated reproducibility and audit goals. No independent task statement was supplied, so broader requirement coverage cannot be verified beyond the task identifier and repository."
},
"lld": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 19,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 86,
"notes": "The LLD is unusually repository-specific, covering real files, build contexts, venv behavior, workflow triggers, failure handling, and rollback. Repository inspection confirms `package = false` in all nine projects, the root dev group, the existing A2A pattern, and the separate torch installs described. Its main technical weakness is retaining unpinned torch through `--inexact`, leaving two images only partially reproducible while some overview language implies complete lock-based images; its caching claims also overstate the benefit where source is copied before sync. Scratch re-lock results, exact exit codes, and the claimed torch 2.14.1 resolution could not be independently reproduced in the read-only environment."
},
"review": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 21,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 88,
"notes": "The review finds concrete, load-bearing issues, including the resolving editable install, undeclared torchvision, lock-only build triggers, generic-template compatibility, and workflow permissions. These findings align with real source such as `docker/Dockerfile.registry`, `.github/workflows/build-registry.yml`, and the absence of torchvision imports in repository Python files. Its largest weakness is treating the unpinned torch exception as resolved merely because it is documented, despite that exception preserving the central reproducibility risk. Claims about unchanged deployment commands are generally supported, although the proposed implementation itself was not available in full for verification."
},
"testing": {
"completeness": 21,
"correctness": 14,
"specificity": 22,
"risk_awareness": 19,
"total": 76,
"notes": "The plan covers lock freshness, negative drift, image builds, metadata compatibility, health checks, CPU torch, rollback, and repeat-build comparison with concrete commands and expected results. Several central oracles are defective: auth and registry runtime stages do not contain the system `uv`, uv-created venvs are not seeded with pip, so multiple `uv pip list` and `python -m pip` fallbacks cannot run as written. The installed-versus-locked comparison uses only `comm -13`, allowing extra unpinned packages, and the first lock loop reports failures without aggregating a failing exit status. Image and integration tests were not executed, so the proposed health, size, and package-equivalence outcomes remain unverified."
},
"implementation": {
"completeness": 19,
"correctness": 16,
"specificity": 20,
"risk_awareness": 15,
"total": 70,
"notes": "The summary describes an end-to-end change across the correct baseline files, and the visible `build-registry.yml` hunk matches tag 1.23.0 exactly while all named Dockerfiles and missing lock targets exist. The submitted patch is truncated during the first generated lockfile, so the load-bearing Dockerfile, root lock, pyproject, and metrics changes cannot be checked or applied from the artifact; the claimed successful `git apply --check` is therefore not independently verifiable. The described implementation also deliberately retains unpinned torch or torchvision installation in two MCP templates via `--inexact`, so those images are not fully reproducible from their locks. The summary honestly discloses that exception and that image and project tests were not run, but its opening claim that every Python image installs dependencies from committed locks overstates the result."
}
},
"task_score": 81.4,
"verdict": "The design work is strong and repository-grounded, but the implementation remains only partially verifiable and preserves unpinned dependencies in two MCP images.",
"judge": {
"model": "openai.gpt-5.6-sol",
"provider": "codex-exec",
"repo_grounded": true,
"evaluated_at": "2026-10-02T22:22:30.993006Z",
"repo_ref": "1.23.0",
"reasoning_effort": "high",
"token_usage": {
"input_tokens": 2091997,
"cached_input_tokens": 1891369,
"cache_write_input_tokens": 200602,
"output_tokens": 12033,
"reasoning_output_tokens": 5328
},
"duration_ms": 148716
}
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,154 @@
{
"task": "build-docker-images-from-uv-lock",
"repo": "https://github.com/agentic-community/mcp-gateway-registry",
"ref": "1.23.0",
"complexity": "medium",
"tags": [
"docker",
"build",
"uv",
"dependencies",
"reproducibility",
"ci",
"fixed-in-1.24.0"
],
"model": "us.anthropic.claude-opus-5-5",
"model_slug": "claude-opus-5-5",
"agent": "omp",
"skill": "swe3",
"provider": "bedrock",
"endpoint": null,
"aws_region": "us-east-1",
"serving": {
"instance_type": "t3.medium",
"tensor_parallel_size": null,
"precision": null,
"context_window": null
},
"artifacts_produced": 6,
"artifacts_expected": 6,
"generation_tokens_per_sec": 67.5,
"token_accounting_warning": null,
"prompt_token_reconciliation": null,
"metrics": {
"note": "Headline metrics as reported by the model API (claude -p); there is no vLLM server for this provider, so no server-side cache telemetry.",
"input_tokens": 78,
"output_tokens": 52542,
"cache_read_tokens": 4631844,
"cache_write_tokens": 120367,
"total_tokens": 4804831,
"total_cost_usd": 2.8372913800000004,
"latency_seconds": 778.3,
"num_turns": 36,
"generation_tokens_per_sec": 67.5,
"sources": {
"input_tokens": "omp_api.usage.input",
"output_tokens": "omp_api.usage.output",
"cache_read_tokens": "omp_api.usage.cache_read_input_tokens",
"cache_write_tokens": "omp_api.usage.cache_creation_input_tokens",
"total_tokens": "total tokens processed once each (issue #136): input + output, plus cache_read + cache_write ONLY when the cache is additive (not a partition of input). An agent with disjoint counts declares that instead of being detected (issue #183).",
"total_cost_usd": "omp_api.total_cost_usd (metered)",
"latency_seconds": "harness wall-clock (or omp_api.duration_ms)",
"num_turns": "omp_api.num_turns",
"generation_tokens_per_sec": "derived: output_tokens / latency_seconds"
}
},
"input_tokens": 78,
"output_tokens": 52542,
"latency_seconds": 778.3,
"num_turns": 36,
"total_cost_usd": 2.8372913800000004,
"is_error": false,
"result_subtype": "success",
"cache_read_tokens": 4631844,
"cache_creation_tokens": 120367,
"run_started_at": "2026-10-02T17:20:00.624997Z",
"run_ended_at": "2026-10-02T17:32:58.934121Z",
"metrics_that_matter": {
"note": "Headline metrics as reported by the model API (claude -p); there is no vLLM server for this provider, so no server-side cache telemetry.",
"input_tokens": 78,
"output_tokens": 52542,
"cache_read_tokens": 4631844,
"cache_write_tokens": 120367,
"total_tokens": 4804831,
"total_cost_usd": 2.8372913800000004,
"latency_seconds": 778.3,
"num_turns": 36,
"generation_tokens_per_sec": 67.5,
"sources": {
"input_tokens": "omp_api.usage.input",
"output_tokens": "omp_api.usage.output",
"cache_read_tokens": "omp_api.usage.cache_read_input_tokens",
"cache_write_tokens": "omp_api.usage.cache_creation_input_tokens",
"total_tokens": "total tokens processed once each (issue #136): input + output, plus cache_read + cache_write ONLY when the cache is additive (not a partition of input). An agent with disjoint counts declares that instead of being detected (issue #183).",
"total_cost_usd": "omp_api.total_cost_usd (metered)",
"latency_seconds": "harness wall-clock (or omp_api.duration_ms)",
"num_turns": "omp_api.num_turns",
"generation_tokens_per_sec": "derived: output_tokens / latency_seconds"
}
},
"evaluation": {
"task": "build-docker-images-from-uv-lock",
"model": "us.anthropic.claude-opus-5-5",
"scores": {
"github_issue": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 20,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 87,
"notes": "The issue precisely identifies all nine tracked pyproject roots and the relevant Dockerfiles, matching the repository at tag 1.23.0. Its baseline claims are grounded: the Dockerfiles use `uv pip install`, four roots lack locks, and the root lock contains torch 2.9.1 plus CUDA and triton packages. The largest deficiency is that excluding the unpinned torch layers in the two full MCP images conflicts with the stated reproducibility and audit goals. No independent task statement was supplied, so broader requirement coverage cannot be verified beyond the task identifier and repository."
},
"lld": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 19,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 86,
"notes": "The LLD is unusually repository-specific, covering real files, build contexts, venv behavior, workflow triggers, failure handling, and rollback. Repository inspection confirms `package = false` in all nine projects, the root dev group, the existing A2A pattern, and the separate torch installs described. Its main technical weakness is retaining unpinned torch through `--inexact`, leaving two images only partially reproducible while some overview language implies complete lock-based images; its caching claims also overstate the benefit where source is copied before sync. Scratch re-lock results, exact exit codes, and the claimed torch 2.14.1 resolution could not be independently reproduced in the read-only environment."
},
"review": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 21,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 88,
"notes": "The review finds concrete, load-bearing issues, including the resolving editable install, undeclared torchvision, lock-only build triggers, generic-template compatibility, and workflow permissions. These findings align with real source such as `docker/Dockerfile.registry`, `.github/workflows/build-registry.yml`, and the absence of torchvision imports in repository Python files. Its largest weakness is treating the unpinned torch exception as resolved merely because it is documented, despite that exception preserving the central reproducibility risk. Claims about unchanged deployment commands are generally supported, although the proposed implementation itself was not available in full for verification."
},
"testing": {
"completeness": 21,
"correctness": 14,
"specificity": 22,
"risk_awareness": 19,
"total": 76,
"notes": "The plan covers lock freshness, negative drift, image builds, metadata compatibility, health checks, CPU torch, rollback, and repeat-build comparison with concrete commands and expected results. Several central oracles are defective: auth and registry runtime stages do not contain the system `uv`, uv-created venvs are not seeded with pip, so multiple `uv pip list` and `python -m pip` fallbacks cannot run as written. The installed-versus-locked comparison uses only `comm -13`, allowing extra unpinned packages, and the first lock loop reports failures without aggregating a failing exit status. Image and integration tests were not executed, so the proposed health, size, and package-equivalence outcomes remain unverified."
},
"implementation": {
"completeness": 19,
"correctness": 16,
"specificity": 20,
"risk_awareness": 15,
"total": 70,
"notes": "The summary describes an end-to-end change across the correct baseline files, and the visible `build-registry.yml` hunk matches tag 1.23.0 exactly while all named Dockerfiles and missing lock targets exist. The submitted patch is truncated during the first generated lockfile, so the load-bearing Dockerfile, root lock, pyproject, and metrics changes cannot be checked or applied from the artifact; the claimed successful `git apply --check` is therefore not independently verifiable. The described implementation also deliberately retains unpinned torch or torchvision installation in two MCP templates via `--inexact`, so those images are not fully reproducible from their locks. The summary honestly discloses that exception and that image and project tests were not run, but its opening claim that every Python image installs dependencies from committed locks overstates the result."
}
},
"task_score": 81.4,
"verdict": "The design work is strong and repository-grounded, but the implementation remains only partially verifiable and preserves unpinned dependencies in two MCP images.",
"judge": {
"model": "openai.gpt-5.6-sol",
"provider": "codex-exec",
"repo_grounded": true,
"evaluated_at": "2026-10-02T22:22:30.993006Z",
"repo_ref": "1.23.0",
"reasoning_effort": "high",
"token_usage": {
"input_tokens": 2091997,
"cached_input_tokens": 1891369,
"cache_write_input_tokens": 200602,
"output_tokens": 12033,
"reasoning_output_tokens": 5328
},
"duration_ms": 148716
}
}
}
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
{
"task": "cli-custom-egress-oauth-provider-flags",
"model": "us.anthropic.claude-opus-5-5",
"scores": {
"github_issue": {
"completeness": 23,
"correctness": 20,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 21,
"total": 87,
"notes": "The issue defines a narrow parity bug, five concrete flags, compatibility expectations, testable acceptance criteria, and explicit exclusions. Its largest factual defect is attributing the failure to resolve_provider's missing-URL message, although registry/api/egress_auth_routes.py validates empty custom URLs first and returns a custom_authorize_url rejection. The five request fields and four corresponding fields in registry/core/schemas.py were verified, but custom_resource is absent from EgressOAuthConfig and no list_providers symbol exists; the repository instead has list_provider_names. No independent task statement or accessible issue #1601 was supplied, limiting verification beyond the task identifier and repository history."
},
"lld": {
"completeness": 23,
"correctness": 20,
"specificity": 24,
"risk_awareness": 23,
"total": 90,
"notes": "The LLD is implementation-ready, accurately locating configure_egress_auth, cmd_egress_configure, the inline parser, JSON request branch, route validation, and replace-on-edit behavior. Its main factual error is claiming registry/core/schemas.py stores all five custom fields when EgressOAuthConfig omits custom_resource, although the raw DocumentDB update path can still persist it. The proposed parameter ordering, is-not-None body assembly, parser choices, and forwarding all fit the verified baseline code and preserve existing request bodies. It also handles SSRF ownership, UI resave loss, rollback, and edit semantics well, but the claimed enum drift test does not prove exact equality if the server enum removes a value."
},
"review": {
"completeness": 22,
"correctness": 22,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 24,
"total": 91,
"notes": "The review finds two genuine defects: omitted custom fields are cleared by registry/api/egress_auth_routes.py, and an exit-code-only argparse test would pass for an unrecognized flag on the baseline. It gives concrete consequences and actionable resolutions, including operator help text and checking stderr for invalid choice. Its largest omission is failing to notice that EgressOAuthConfig lacks custom_resource, and Pixel's claim that UI || undefined and CLI is-not-None semantics are identical overlooks explicit empty strings. The modal resave loss and shell-history exposure are repository-supported risks, while the existence of a follow-up UI issue cannot be verified."
},
"testing": {
"completeness": 21,
"correctness": 17,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 21,
"total": 82,
"notes": "The six proposed unit tests have concrete request-body, endpoint, forwarding, omission, enum, and pre-network rejection oracles that directly cover the regression. The largest correctness problem is expecting server detail text from CLI HTTP 400 failures, while RegistryClient._make_request only logs parsed response details for 422 and otherwise re-raises requests.HTTPError. Several manual commands also assume unlisted servers such as /github-mcp and /internal-mcp exist, and the consent test uses reserved idp.example.com URLs despite requiring a real test IdP. The negative SSRF, malformed-resource, compatibility, and replace-on-edit scenarios are valuable, but none were executed and the stated E2E setup is not runnable unchanged."
},
"implementation": {
"completeness": 23,
"correctness": 22,
"specificity": 23,
"risk_awareness": 22,
"total": 90,
"notes": "The embedded patch implements the design end to end by extending api/registry_client.py, forwarding values in api/registry_management.py, adding all five parser flags, tests, and documentation. Its contexts and symbols match the exact 1.28.0 baseline, and the body assembly, endpoint, argparse choices, and test import pattern follow verified repository conventions. The largest concrete defect is the documentation command's unquoted <atlassian-app-client-id> and <atlassian-app-secret> placeholders, which shell parsing treats as input redirections rather than arguments. The summary honestly states tests were not run; its git apply --check claim could not be independently reproduced because no standalone patch.diff file exists, though the submitted diff context matches."
}
},
"task_score": 88.0,
"verdict": "This is a strong, repository-grounded submission with a correct core implementation, limited mainly by several factual documentation claims and a manual testing plan whose HTTP-error and environment assumptions are not valid as written.",
"judge": {
"model": "openai.gpt-5.6-sol",
"provider": "codex-exec",
"repo_grounded": true,
"evaluated_at": "2026-10-02T22:24:12.980361Z",
"repo_ref": "1.28.0",
"reasoning_effort": "high",
"token_usage": {
"input_tokens": 590988,
"cached_input_tokens": 486767,
"cache_write_input_tokens": 104205,
"output_tokens": 7910,
"reasoning_output_tokens": 3763
},
"duration_ms": 101953
}
}
Loading
Loading