Only first key in multiple key if-clause is parsed

[PancakeFriday]

Description

I am using the american-physics-society bibliography style and I noticed that webpages aren't formatted correctly. So I downloaded the csl file and it has the following else-if clause:

<else-if type="post-weblog interview manuscript pamphlet personal_communication post post-weblog speech webpage">

However, in the bibtex file @online or @webpage does not descend into this block and is instead caught in the else at the very end. If I modify the else-if to the following:

<else-if type="webpage">

then the entry is parsed correctly; the typst pdf now renders the url as well.

[Drodt]

The problem seems to me that the else-if has the match="all" attribute implicitly. This means that all conditions must be met and the way havagriva checks this is by treating all types as unique conditions. So, for this to work, the entry must have the type "post-weblob, interview, ..." all at the same time.

This seems wrong to me, but the spec is unclear. I'll check how citeproc does it.

[Drodt]

As a quick work-around: Just add match="any"

[Drodt]

Hayagriva's behavior seems right. You should add the match=any part. Maybe raise an issue in the CSL styles repository so it can be fixed over there as well.

[PancakeFriday]

Okay I think there is some confusion with the specs, but I agree with you and I will raise the issue. I used the visual editor https://editor.citationstyles.org/codeEditor/ and there, this works:

<else-if type="figure interview manuscript pamphlet personal_communication post post-weblog speech webpage" match="all">

This works (since URL is present)

<else-if type="figure interview manuscript pamphlet personal_communication post post-weblog speech webpage" match="all" variable="URL">

This does not work (since collection-title is not present)

<else-if type="figure interview manuscript pamphlet personal_communication post post-weblog speech webpage" match="all" variable="URL collection-title">

I'm wondering if match always only matches one of the types (since at least for BibTeX you can only have one type anyways). But I couldn't find that in the specs. However in either case, the american-physics-society.csl is incosistent because it has match="any" on all other else-ifs. Thanks for your help, I'll post the issue here https://github.com/citation-style-language/styles

[PancakeFriday]

citation-style-language/styles#7360