|
1 | | -# Authored finalized review context controls |
| 1 | +# Finalized inherited review context evidence |
2 | 2 |
|
3 | | -Date: 2026-10-12 (Europe/Berlin). Protected baseline c6af68a0, signed specification 34620aa7 |
4 | | -and compatibility specification 2557eb1b precede these unchanged authored controls. |
5 | | -Owner djm81 approved the exact two-selector mapping a0ec5078 and prerequisite head grants. |
| 3 | +Date: 2026-10-12 (Europe/Berlin). Protected base c6af68a0 after reviewed #767. Signed specification |
| 4 | +34620aa7 precedes authored controls. Canonical two-selector mapping a0ec5078 was accepted by owner djm81. |
6 | 5 |
|
7 | | -Actual #743 run 38303860784 passes planned reconciliation but rejects its planned receipt as finalized |
8 | | -Code Review proof. Both actual consumer shells reproduce that defect locally: two genuine failures, |
9 | | -zero errors/skips. The ordinary frozen-provider final positive control passes. Test fixtures model |
10 | | -Git and artifact boundaries and are not published as execution proof. |
| 6 | +## Genuine failing-before evidence |
11 | 7 |
|
12 | | -Authored test SHA256: ee736256f43eaf546bb93c763bdd8f5d4540e20a1bcb1cb75b3fe44d8dd2109c. |
13 | | -The correction is preserved locally and is absent from this authored commit. Genuine native RED remains |
14 | | -pending. Final execution, all required CI and completed review remain mandatory before separate merge |
15 | | -approval. Target #719/#743/#751 remain unmerged. |
| 8 | +Actual #743 run 38303860784 passes authenticated planned reconciliation, then the immutable Code Review |
| 9 | +provider rejects its planning report: finalized proof requires execution_proof.run_stage=final. |
| 10 | +The final clean authored control bytes reproduce two genuine failures in 3.60 seconds, zero errors/skips, |
| 11 | +against protected behavior. The ordinary genuine-final positive control passes. Fixtures are explicitly |
| 12 | +synthetic Git/service boundary inputs and are never published as actual passing execution proof. |
| 13 | + |
| 14 | +## Initial local passing candidate |
| 15 | + |
| 16 | +Both actual independent/final workflow review shells now pass with the frozen provider final-context |
| 17 | +reader. They preserve full inherited protected-dev Python paths, full enforcement and unchanged genuine |
| 18 | +root proof bytes, leaving planning receipts unchanged. Producer-only, foreign/incomplete proof, foreign |
| 19 | +artifact repository, expiry, corruption, ambiguity, oversized metadata, stale root checks and changed live |
| 20 | +native head all fail closed. Ordinary finalized context remains accepted. Source helper bytes come only |
| 21 | +from protected origin/dev; live native/event resolution and root checks are repeated before retrieval. |
| 22 | + |
| 23 | +Full smart suite: 3313 passed, ten skips, two existing dependency warnings, 197.71 seconds. Raw JUnit |
| 24 | +contains 3323 cases with zero failures/errors. All 787 tracked source/test/script/workflow/tool/delivery |
| 25 | +inputs match before/after execution. Expected failure/timeout/coverage console diagnostics originate in |
| 26 | +passing negative smart-test harness controls, not failing cases. |
| 27 | + |
| 28 | +Format/lint, zero-error canonical typing (1522 existing warnings), YAML, strict selected OpenSpec, |
| 29 | +documentation, contracts/scenarios, three frozen audits, licenses, trust, Bandit/Semgrep and four strict |
| 30 | +manifest signatures pass. No signed module asset changed. Local SpecFact helper/test review has zero |
| 31 | +findings after resolving all new complexity/shape/type advisories; no rule or threshold is suppressed. |
| 32 | +Frozen delivery, coherent 0.55.9 source/lock metadata and exact CI export payload parity pass. Strict |
| 33 | +PyPI-ahead confirms 0.55.9 > 0.55.4. Proof-bound provider pins and all review/authority gates are retained. |
| 34 | +Repository YAML command retains existing mapping/archive style diagnostics; its successful exit is not |
| 35 | +claimed as zero formatting diagnostics. Newly authored mapping validates at planned maturity with no findings. |
| 36 | + |
| 37 | +## Pending required publication |
| 38 | + |
| 39 | +Owner acceptance/grants and genuine native RED are retained; unchanged-test signed implementation, exact-head provenance/final execution, required CI and completed |
| 40 | +review remain required. Local results do not substitute for those gates. Separate owner merge authorization |
| 41 | +is still required after final hosted validation. Target #719/#743/#751 remain unmerged. After protected |
| 42 | +integration, reprove root on the new base and validate both planning consumers before final readiness. |
| 43 | + |
| 44 | +Full touched-Python review independently retains three unchanged promotion-fixture advisories |
| 45 | +(one naming warning and two fixture-shape information findings), exactly matching protected c6af68a0. |
| 46 | +Explicit exception: these pre-existing fixtures are outside the correction, and changing them would |
| 47 | +expand accepted proof/control scope. No new finding or rule suppression is accepted. |
| 48 | + |
| 49 | +## Final compatibility-preserving candidate |
| 50 | + |
| 51 | +Primary frozen provider lifecycle explicitly supports `passing-after-legacy-tdd-ledger`. Signed |
| 52 | +compatibility specification precedes a real one-failure/one-pass control: ordinary approved legacy |
| 53 | +context passes the immutable provider, while the transport-only RED field restriction rejects it. |
| 54 | +The correction removes that invented restriction and retains the provider's complete proof/basis |
| 55 | +validation, authentic exact root, artifact integrity, full inherited review and unchanged planning receipts. |
| 56 | + |
| 57 | +Final clean authored bytes again reproduce two genuine failures against protected workflow behavior |
| 58 | +with zero errors/skips before restoration. Both complete actual workflow/provider controls pass, including |
| 59 | +ordinary and inherited RED/approved legacy contexts and all forgery cases. New helper/test review has |
| 60 | +zero findings; canonical types still have zero errors and the same 1522 existing warnings. |
| 61 | + |
| 62 | +The full suite was repeated after this behavior correction: 3313 passed, ten skips, two existing warnings, |
| 63 | +198.52 seconds. Raw JUnit has zero failures/errors; all 787 inputs are unchanged. Test SHA256 |
| 64 | +ee736256f43eaf546bb93c763bdd8f5d4540e20a1bcb1cb75b3fe44d8dd2109c. Final native proof and protected integration remain pending. |
| 65 | + |
| 66 | +## Genuine native authored RED retained |
| 67 | + |
| 68 | +Signed authored head `94fcc52b066d2c519727beb13165edd0da5eab14`, native run `38313685016`, |
| 69 | +artifact `11775304337` (`requirements-evidence`) reproduce two real mapped failures, zero errors/skips. |
| 70 | +Reconciler reports red/pass with no findings; the overall workflow correctly requires implementation |
| 71 | +and final execution. Artifact service SHA256 `327620bb69480d3b8246dc906a7d29e8546504ca458c1427691aeaff7120806c` |
| 72 | +and JUnit SHA256 `099c2f7c2cea3df69ff9017120bfd303bb410208253ed3d47bde8d8355024e20` verify. |
| 73 | +Authored test bytes retain SHA256 `ee736256f43eaf546bb93c763bdd8f5d4540e20a1bcb1cb75b3fe44d8dd2109c` unchanged. |
| 74 | +Exact mapping acceptance is recorded as djm81; verified signed authored-head authority comment 6133340014. |
| 75 | +Native final execution, required CI and completed review remain required before separate merge approval. |
0 commit comments