add workout command and the timing and date

[nguyin]

The schedule feature works well, but when you omit the timing, the program will immediately input the current time as the time recorded though the date may be in the past. It may not be the best when the date is already specified as in the past because it does not really make sense to put a previous date and the current time for recording purposes.

There should be an error message instead to tell the user to input the date that they exercised if the date was in the past.

[nus-se-bot]

Team's Response

There appears to be a misunderstanding about add workout. add workout records workouts and the calories burned doing (completed/past ones in conventional usage, but users can record in advance if they want). It gives users the ability to record entries in the past due to possibility of forgetfulness.

Scheduling of workouts is done by add schedule and is future-based, where workouts are assumed to be scheduled ahead of time in the future. add schedule will not retain workouts scheduled in the past and will delete/reschedule them depending on wheheter they are recurring workouts or not.

Items for the Tester to Verify

❓ Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

• I disagree

Reason for disagreement: Yes, there appears to be a misunderstanding but on the team's part as they have misread what I have wrote.

Yes, the add workout command allows the user to record their past workouts, that is fine. The problem is when you omit the time, despite a past date being entered, the program will just choose to input the current time. (see the screenshot again)

This does not make sense in the feature because why would the person input a past date but have the current time? So the program should warn the user when there are problems like this.

---