You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
RcUninit was discussed in
rust-lang/libs-team#90https://internals.rust-lang.org/t/an-alternative-to-rc-new-cyclic/22849/6rust-lang#112566
RcUninit allows the user to construct cyclic data structures without
using `Rc::new_cyclic`, which allows cyclic constructions across await
points. It also allows you to create long linked lists without
overflowing the stack.
This is an alternative to `UniqueRc`. While `UniqueRc` does allow for cyclic
data structures to be created, it must be done by mutating the UniqueRc.
Mutation is prone to creating reference cycles. Construction-only assignment
of fields, without any mutation to "set" the struct afterwards cannot generate
reference cycles. It's also more cumbersome to work with.
For instance, if we have objects A, B, and C, and we want these to connect as
`A => B => C -> A` (`=>` being strong, `->` being weak), then we must do
something along the following lines.
let mut a_uniq = UniqueRc::new(A::new());
let a_weak = UniqueRc::downgrade(&a_uniq);
let c = Rc::new(C::new(a_weak));
let b = Rc::new(B::new(c));
a_uniq.set_b(b);
let a = a_uniq.into_rc();
To implement `A::set_b`, the field `A::b` must either be
- `Option<Rc<B>>`: Requiring unwrap/clone for each access.
- `MaybeUninit<Rc<B>>`: Requiring unsafe.
- `Weak<B>`: Requiring upgrade for every access.
The above also makes it easier to make mistakes in more complex programs where
we don't have the full picture. It is not hard to change the above into
`Rc<RefCell<A>>`, and then provide this pointer to `C`, which would cause a
reference cycle to be created once `a.borrow_mut().set_b(b)` gets called.
On the other hand RcUninit doesn't have this problem, since initialization
is deferred. The equivalent would look like the following.
let a_uninit = RcUninit::new();
let b_uninit = RcUninit::new();
let c_uninit = RcUninit::new();
let c = c_uninit.init(C::new(a_uninit.weak()));
let b = b_uninit.init(B::new(c));
let a = a_uninit.init(b);
This creates the structure (A => B => C -> A)
0 commit comments