Minor bugs

[Essien-Ge]

Contact Details

essien.ge@philips.com

Section Number

XX.1.1.X VHL Sharer
1:XX.1.2.2 Retrieve Trust List with DID [ITI-YY2]
1:XX.2.1 Sign Manifest Request Option (VHL Receiver)
1:XX.2 Actor Options

What is wrong

1. XX.1.1.X VHL Sharer "The VHL Sharer generates a VHL, provides the VHL to a VHL Holder, and responds to requests from a VHL Sharer to utilize the VHL." - VHL Sharer responds to request from a VHL Sharer? Is this a mistake.
   2.1:XX.1.2.2 Retrieve Trust List with DID [ITI-YY2] "They do not have pre-established mechanisms to retrieve PKI material from the Trust Anchor" pre-established mechanism was refered to as a main feature of VHL against SHL, so it seems it is core to YY2, however here it says YY2 is used when not having pre-established mechanism. Maybe good to use another word.
   3.1:XX.2.1 Sign Manifest Request Option (VHL Receiver) says "This option provides: Mutual authentication between VHL Receiver and VHL Sharer" here just VHL receiver so maybe itself not mutual but enable sharer to authenticate receiver.
2. 1:XX.2 Actor Options - have you missed Sign Manifest Request Option for sharer?

Describe the solution you'd like

No response

Relevant log output

Priority

{"Low" => "Typo or other minor classification that an editor can manage. Requires no group discussion."}

Code of Conduct

• I agree to follow the IHE Code of Conduct

[oliveregger]

F2F Discussion:

XX.1.1.X VHL Sharer "The VHL Sharer generates a VHL, provides the VHL to a VHL Holder, and responds to requests from a VHL Sharer to utilize the VHL." - VHL Sharer responds to request from a VHL Sharer? Is this a mistake.

Yes, we think this should be: and responds to requests from a VHL SharerVHL Receiver to utilize the VHL.

2.1:XX.1.2.2 Retrieve Trust List with DID [ITI-YY2] "They do not have pre-established mechanisms to retrieve PKI material from the Trust Anchor" pre-established mechanism was refered to as a main feature of VHL against SHL, so it seems it is core to YY2, however here it says YY2 is used when not having pre-established mechanism. They do not have pre-established mechanisms to retrieve PKI material from the

defer to @litlfred and @ritikarawlani

3.1:XX.2.1 Sign Manifest Request Option (VHL Receiver) says "This option provides: Mutual authentication between VHL Receiver and VHL Sharer" here just VHL receiver so maybe itself not mutual but enable sharer to authenticate receiver.

1. could the actor options be in the same order (Sign Manifest Request, Include DocumentReference or DocumentReference, Sign Manifest Request)

2. we should remove the actor name out of the option for the 2 actor descriptions:
   1:XX.2.1 Sign Manifest Request Option (VHL Receiver)
   1:XX.2.2 Include DocumentReference Option (VHL Sharer)
   Here the actor option for the VHL Receiver should also be described.

1:XX.2 Actor Options - have you missed Sign Manifest Request Option for sharer?

-> fixed if removed and text adapted in 1:XX.2.1, see above