Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Unilateral closure when a peer was offline for a while Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH #8067

Open
vincenzopalazzo opened this issue Feb 7, 2025 · 3 comments
Open

Unilateral closure when a peer was offline for a while Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH #8067

vincenzopalazzo opened this issue Feb 7, 2025 · 3 comments
Assignees
@rustyrussell
Milestone
v25.05

Comments

@vincenzopalazzo
Copy link
Contributor

Running two core lightning nodes, that are running two versions of different versions v24.05 and v24.11.1.

My node that runs v24.11.1 was offline for quite some time, and the channel between the two cln instance dropped on chain with the following message: Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH

v24.05

2025-02-05T15:09:34.061Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: Connect IN
2025-02-05T15:09:34.062Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: peer_out WIRE_INIT
2025-02-05T15:09:34.208Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: peer_in WIRE_INIT
2025-02-05T15:09:34.209Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-gossipd: seeker: disabling gossip
2025-02-05T15:09:34.210Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: Handed peer, entering loop
2025-02-05T15:09:34.212Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: peer_out WIRE_GOSSIP_TIMESTAMP_FILTER
2025-02-05T15:09:34.244Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-gossipd: Bad gossip order: channel_announcement: no unspent txout 861963x2204x0
2025-02-05T15:09:34.245Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: peer_out WIRE_WARNING
2025-02-05T15:09:34.363Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: Activating for message WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH
2025-02-05T15:09:34.364Z UNUSUAL 03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-lightningd: Unknown channel 0de3746f3d84b03df198114f007c2b46c15bf04d73191aa2cae2d94d5219baa1 for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH
2025-02-05T15:09:34.364Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-lightningd: Telling connectd to send error 00110de3746f3d84b03df198114f007c2b46c15bf04d73191aa2cae2d94d5219baa1002c556e6b6e6f776e206368616e6e656c20666f7220574952455f4348414e4e454c5f524545535441424c495348
2025-02-05T15:09:34.365Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: peer_out WIRE_ERROR
2025-02-05T15:09:34.365Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-connectd: discard_peer
2025-02-05T15:09:34.366Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-lightningd: peer_disconnect_done
2025-02-05T15:09:34.366Z DEBUG   03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae-lightningd: Not reconnecting: no active channel
2025-02-05T15:09:34.367Z DEBUG   plugin-funder: Cleaning up inflights for peer id 03e2408a49f07d2f4083a47344138ef89e7617e63919202c92aa8d49b574a560ae

v24.11.1

2025-02-05T15:09:34.135Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-lightningd: Peer says it sees our address as: 65.108.246.14:57864
2025-02-05T15:09:34.136Z DEBUG   lightningd: best_remote_addr: peer 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4 gave addr 65.108.246.14:9735 (preferred)
2025-02-05T15:09:34.136Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-connectd: Handed peer, entering loop
2025-02-05T15:09:34.136Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Peer has reconnected, state CHANNELD_NORMAL: connecting subd
2025-02-05T15:09:34.148Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: pid 2243672, msgfd 86
2025-02-05T15:09:34.148Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Already have funding locked in
2025-02-05T15:09:34.149Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: option_static_remotekey = 1, option_anchor_outputs = 0 option_anchors_zero_fee_htlc_tx = 1
2025-02-05T15:09:34.150Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: init REMOTE: remote_per_commit = 026b13e7a34095b030b284992c6a2c4ff20ddc9468af9d2ea5e403a2250fae5507, old_remote_per_commit = 027df0dabd231f3c1b5a998ce3fc4dd4e063f2555017c3c5207888a1d13e76d740 next_idx_local = 5733 next_idx_remote = 5734 revocations_received = 5732 feerates { RCVD_ADD_ACK_REVOCATION:1255 } range 253-5000 blockheights { RCVD_ADD_ACK_REVOCATION:0 }, our current 881664
2025-02-05T15:09:34.150Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: Restoring HTLC 0/1: id=2861 amount=726320msat cltv=881812 payment_hash=725076197ae8aff5bd06c729eba5394221461189ca0b51e9d403f0ab6abdb7f5 (failed)
2025-02-05T15:09:34.150Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: NEW:: HTLC REMOTE 2861 = SENT_REMOVE_COMMIT/RCVD_REMOVE_COMMIT 
2025-02-05T15:09:34.150Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: peer_out WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH
2025-02-05T15:09:34.150Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: billboard: Sent reestablish, waiting for theirs
2025-02-05T15:09:34.151Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-hsmd: Got WIRE_HSMD_GET_PER_COMMITMENT_POINT
2025-02-05T15:09:34.152Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-hsmd: Got WIRE_HSMD_GET_PER_COMMITMENT_POINT
2025-02-05T15:09:34.319Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-connectd: peer_in WIRE_GOSSIP_TIMESTAMP_FILTER
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-connectd: peer_in WIRE_WARNING
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z INFO    029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-connectd: Received WIRE_WARNING: WARNING: channel_announcement: no unspent txout 861963x2204x0
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-lightningd: peer_disconnect_done
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-connectd: Will try reconnect in 1 seconds
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: peer_in WIRE_ERROR
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-channeld-chan#1400: billboard perm: Received ERROR channel 0de3746f3d84b03df198114f007c2b46c15bf04d73191aa2cae2d94d5219baa1: Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH
2025-02-05T15:09:34.439Z UNUSUAL 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Peer permanent failure in CHANNELD_NORMAL: channeld: received ERROR channel 0de3746f3d84b03df198114f007c2b46c15bf04d73191aa2cae2d94d5219baa1: Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH (reason=protocol)
2025-02-05T15:09:34.440Z INFO    029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: State changed from CHANNELD_NORMAL to AWAITING_UNILATERAL
2025-02-05T15:09:34.442Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: We have 3 anchor points to use
2025-02-05T15:09:34.446Z DEBUG   plugin-funder: Cleaning up inflights for peer id 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4
2025-02-05T15:09:38.611Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Low-priority anchorspend aiming for block 883680 (feerate 253)
2025-02-05T15:09:38.612Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Low-priority anchorspend aiming for block 883680 (feerate 253)
2025-02-05T15:19:35.055Z DEBUG   lightningd: best_remote_addr: peer 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4 gave addr 65.108.246.14:9735 (preferred)
2025-02-05T15:22:38.733Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for a1ba19524dd9e2caa21a19734df05bc1462b7c004f1198f13db0843d6f74e30d:0: 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986
2025-02-05T15:22:38.733Z UNUSUAL 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Peer permanent failure in AWAITING_UNILATERAL: Funding transaction spent: onchain txid 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986 (reason=onchain)
2025-02-05T15:22:38.733Z UNUSUAL 029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Not dropping our unilateral close onchain since we already saw 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986 confirm.
2025-02-05T15:22:38.733Z INFO    029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: State changed from AWAITING_UNILATERAL to FUNDING_SPEND_SEEN
2025-02-05T15:22:38.743Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: pid 2245117, msgfd 82
2025-02-05T15:22:38.743Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: channel->static_remotekey_start[LOCAL] 0
2025-02-05T15:22:38.781Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output a1ba19524dd9e2caa21a19734df05bc1462b7c004f1198f13db0843d6f74e30d:0: FUNDING_TRANSACTION/FUNDING_OUTPUT
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Remote per-commit point: 026b13e7a34095b030b284992c6a2c4ff20ddc9468af9d2ea5e403a2250fae5507
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Old remote per-commit point: 027df0dabd231f3c1b5a998ce3fc4dd4e063f2555017c3c5207888a1d13e76d740
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: reducing max_possible_feerate from 1255...
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: ... to 1255
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: commitnum = 5732, revocations_received = 5732
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Their unilateral tx, old commit point
2025-02-05T15:22:38.782Z INFO    029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: State changed from FUNDING_SPEND_SEEN to ONCHAIN
2025-02-05T15:22:38.806Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard perm: Tracking their unilateral close
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Resolved FUNDING_TRANSACTION/FUNDING_OUTPUT by THEIR_UNILATERAL (5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986)
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Deriving keyset 5732: per_commit_point=027df0dabd231f3c1b5a998ce3fc4dd4e063f2555017c3c5207888a1d13e76d740 self_payment_basepoint=03e353b1f01a62e822aa7ba60a28e01aad3406ea0635eeb844831e1c529378d971 other_payment_basepoint=03e0b8622656bb6b6cca732350a0de6e80ede1fdbea803cb6996b890cbecb93365 self_htlc_basepoint=03a499796da56ded9fa77351713cbaf6ed23fb20413d560b7ad2f3a52dd03a70d4 other_htlc_basepoint=03722f7de3868dfa7966085ea286690f79a4a6f163a932c589b67fd0e89368eac2 self_delayed_basepoint=030cf7b51a57d228e7dd4643633f73512e56100ca96089165fc198fd48e26798ac other_revocation_basepoint=0257271377ca589a44657899d669e1324d5714fe3b30d8d890cb9b4811028621b0
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Deconstructing unilateral tx: 5732 using keyset:  self_revocation_key: 03a000745d0dd34ef40ef365796c1f7bf66f212722beff053d9c04f835bafb41f3 self_delayed_payment_key: 03e3826b93a734f683a31c9141f277ccfad22d880a0bc63198b2b2b50c2e6551fa self_payment_key: 03455f319d0767f0ec293d3d25fc218364ee2644df8dc80bf1b1f879c2779e462e other_payment_key: 03e0b8622656bb6b6cca732350a0de6e80ede1fdbea803cb6996b890cbecb93365 self_htlc_key: 035d369cf0817dea9d7440709603b4bfbe9679b6cd02889485b4c739bdece06868 other_htlc_key: 03ca9f6706704f7d6b0715620edf8e652b9fe1b1c9fa1ea37fcbbb9ec378bcc2d8
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Output 0: 00204d8e382405ab92a6c0c12a1c8c72aeefe0d5123c9490f83e58abf7616bcfe1c8
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Output 1: 0020988d4ae48b3a628e1aa5a83a5e6770de0f5d560a45bfd06d5bf300e1e8606b38
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Output 2: 0020234eb2443a38a510377eb7281788e7778b38aca1066890db149c77417b539535
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Output 3: 00203802fe6debc5c2f973493bcfdb73103daccca7ce964b4cf69223de6d3c81e55e
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Output 4: 00208ff81801b5b23747c922166ba71eb9c6b92ffc7e99b1dd03b7aa2aa719a7db5c
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Script to-them: 144: 00208ff81801b5b23747c922166ba71eb9c6b92ffc7e99b1dd03b7aa2aa719a7db5c (632103a000745d0dd34ef40ef365796c1f7bf66f212722beff053d9c04f835bafb41f367029000b2752103e3826b93a734f683a31c9141f277ccfad22d880a0bc63198b2b2b50c2e6551fa68ac)
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Script to-me: 00203802fe6debc5c2f973493bcfdb73103daccca7ce964b4cf69223de6d3c81e55e
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:0: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_US
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Ignoring output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:0: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_US
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:1: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_THEM
2025-02-05T15:22:38.812Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Ignoring output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:1: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_THEM
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:2: THEIR_UNILATERAL/THEIR_HTLC
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Propose ignoring THEIR_UNILATERAL/THEIR_HTLC as THEIR_HTLC_TIMEOUT_TO_THEM after block 881812 (-2 more blocks)
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Ignoring output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:2: THEIR_UNILATERAL/THEIR_HTLC
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:3: THEIR_UNILATERAL/OUTPUT_TO_US
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Ignoring output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:3: THEIR_UNILATERAL/OUTPUT_TO_US
2025-02-05T15:22:38.813Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: adding utxo to watch 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:3, csv 1
2025-02-05T15:22:38.815Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Tracking output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:4: THEIR_UNILATERAL/DELAYED_OUTPUT_TO_THEM
2025-02-05T15:22:38.815Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Ignoring output 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:4: THEIR_UNILATERAL/DELAYED_OUTPUT_TO_THEM
2025-02-05T15:22:38.815Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:22:45.098Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:2: 03a41685b1980267927f7abc5f3ca2003dc141a30e15242d9bf01024ab09a842
2025-02-05T15:22:45.140Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:22:45.140Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:22:45.140Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:24:02.861Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:0: 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c
2025-02-05T15:24:02.861Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:1: 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:24:02.889Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:24:28.019Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c:0: a4cbcfc462c0f6659e452e38bf385a432ed3138eb6226b39991f342e0100449c
2025-02-05T15:24:28.019Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c:0: a4cbcfc462c0f6659e452e38bf385a432ed3138eb6226b39991f342e0100449c
2025-02-05T15:24:28.048Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:24:28.048Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Notified about tx 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c output 0 spend, but we don't care
2025-02-05T15:24:28.048Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:24:28.048Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:24:28.048Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:24:28.049Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Notified about tx 9e342fadaf1c720756f1ecd66f8df4c363de9f47c1be7625e59dea861d5b9e0c output 0 spend, but we don't care
2025-02-05T15:24:28.049Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:24:28.049Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:34:08.592Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 5aa795ac2a197419a34f4aabdf235974e76ec9deb525000441e37d3986cd6986:4: ca1150bf2da8f9f7e527d99963b3977d2c6eafd96c71cb173fb1814eb0d650f0
2025-02-05T15:34:08.610Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:34:08.610Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:34:08.610Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T15:34:18.614Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 03a41685b1980267927f7abc5f3ca2003dc141a30e15242d9bf01024ab09a842:0: 12800015a06fe6567cdaed14e96a6ae50a6d361db0c992d6c5e7165facc7d6cb
2025-02-05T15:34:18.624Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T15:34:18.624Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Notified about tx 03a41685b1980267927f7abc5f3ca2003dc141a30e15242d9bf01024ab09a842 output 0 spend, but we don't care
2025-02-05T15:34:18.624Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T15:34:18.624Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:10:27.466Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Got UTXO spend for 03a41685b1980267927f7abc5f3ca2003dc141a30e15242d9bf01024ab09a842:1: c4606944416eef44fb5592d378a9a54838d491c10d5ac5f58122c302a291bb50
2025-02-05T16:10:27.489Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT
2025-02-05T16:10:27.489Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Notified about tx 03a41685b1980267927f7abc5f3ca2003dc141a30e15242d9bf01024ab09a842 output 1 spend, but we don't care
2025-02-05T16:10:27.489Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: REPLY WIRE_ONCHAIND_SPENT_REPLY with 0 fds
2025-02-05T16:10:27.489Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:12:07.136Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Funding tx a1ba19524dd9e2caa21a19734df05bc1462b7c004f1198f13db0843d6f74e30d depth 20460 of 3
2025-02-05T16:12:07.136Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: Funding tx a1ba19524dd9e2caa21a19734df05bc1462b7c004f1198f13db0843d6f74e30d confirmed, but peer in state ONCHAIN
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_DEPTH
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_DEPTH
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_DEPTH
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 100 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Got new message WIRE_ONCHAIND_DEPTH
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: Sending 0 missing htlc messages
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: FUNDING_TRANSACTION/FUNDING_OUTPUT->THEIR_UNILATERAL depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_US->SELF depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: THEIR_UNILATERAL/ANCHOR_TO_THEM->SELF depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: THEIR_UNILATERAL/THEIR_HTLC->SELF depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: THEIR_UNILATERAL/OUTPUT_TO_US->SELF depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: THEIR_UNILATERAL/DELAYED_OUTPUT_TO_THEM->SELF depth 609
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z DEBUG   029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-onchaind-chan#1400: billboard: All outputs resolved: waiting 0 more blocks before forgetting channel
2025-02-05T16:12:07.155Z INFO    029ef2ce43571727104099576c633b2233bfeb8dc18b476f93540a32207da9e9a4-chan#1400: onchaind complete, forgetting peer
@vincenzopalazzo vincenzopalazzo changed the title Unilateral closure when a peer is offline for a while Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH Unilateral closure when a peer was offline for a while Unknown channel for WIRE_CHANNEL_REESTABLISH Feb 7, 2025
@whitslack
Copy link
Collaborator

The v24.05 node had already unilaterally closed the channel while the v24.11.1 node was offline. Not a bug.

@rustyrussell
Copy link
Contributor

We could dig up the closed channel details and reply, though. This would help them get unstuck if they've lost their db.

@rustyrussell rustyrussell added this to the v25.05 milestone Feb 7, 2025
@rustyrussell rustyrussell self-assigned this Feb 7, 2025
@vincenzopalazzo
Copy link
Contributor Author

vincenzopalazzo commented Feb 7, 2025 •
edited
Loading

The v24.05 node had already unilaterally closed the channel while the v24.11.1 node was offline. Not a bug.

Yes, but I probably need to check older logs. I also handle v24.05 and didn’t close the channel, so something likely occurred. It could be that I forgot closing it, though that seems improbable.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@rustyrussell rustyrussell

Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
v25.05
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@rustyrussell @whitslack @vincenzopalazzo